Do You Have to Be Perfect to Lose Weight?

Today I want to talk about being perfect.

And in my funniest voice possible I want to remind you that "ain't nobody perfect."

Here's a pattern I see all the time as a coach. Someone starts a program, does great for two or three weeks, then has a rough stretch — a birthday weekend, a stressful week at work, a vacation. And in their mind, that's it. They "failed the program."

But here's the thing. They didn't fail.

They just didn't have the proper expectation of what success looks like.

Why going off plan isn't failing

Success isn't perfect. It never was.

When you believe success means following the plan 100% of the time, every normal life event becomes a failure. And nobody can out-willpower a definition of success that's impossible to meet.

Life is too unpredictable and you will face too many obstacles to be perfect. So if perfection is the standard, you will feel like trash all the time — because you're trying to achieve the impossible.

The people who get long-term results aren't the ones who never miss. They're the ones who miss, shrug, and get right back to it.

What the research says about all-or-nothing thinking

This isn't just coach talk. Researchers who study weight regain have found that "dichotomous thinking" — seeing your eating and exercise as either perfect or ruined, with nothing in between — is one of the strongest predictors of gaining the weight back after losing it.

It makes sense when you think about it. If one off-plan meal means the day is "ruined," it's a short hop to "I'll start fresh Monday," and a few of those stretches can undo weeks of good work. The off-plan meal was never the problem. The story you told yourself about it was.

Meanwhile, people who treat a slip as a single event — one meal, one missed workout, not a verdict on who they are — tend to get back on track faster and keep their results. A lapse only becomes a collapse if you let it.

What success actually looks like

So if success isn't perfection, what is it? Here's my personal list.

For me, success is learning lessons from mistakes.

For me, success is getting right back on track after a rough patch.

For me, success is keeping my goals front of mind even when I'm not putting it all together.

For me, success is consistency over very long periods of time.

For me, success is ditching the all-or-nothing mindset.

That's me! It might not be you. Your list might include things like making it to three workouts even on a chaotic week, or packing a lunch most days, or getting to bed on time more often than not.

But in order to be successful long term, you can't be perfect. So I hope you really dig down and actually identify what success looks like for you — and what progress really looks like. Let that guide you instead of perfection.

Three things to do after an imperfect week

If you've just come off a rough patch, here's the playbook:

Get back on track at the very next opportunity. Not Monday. Not after the holidays. The next meal, the next morning, the next scheduled workout. The faster the bounce-back, the smaller the blip.

Zoom out before you judge. One week tells you almost nothing. Look at the month, or the last three months. If the overall trend is you showing up most of the time, you're winning — even if this week wasn't pretty.

Make showing up easier than deciding. This is honestly the biggest reason our group classes work so well. When boot camp, spin, yoga or women's-only strength is already booked in your calendar at one of our Halifax, Bedford, Dartmouth or Truro locations, an imperfect week doesn't get to renegotiate your whole routine. You just show up to the next class, and the streak carries on.

Progress over perfection, always

You're going to have off days, off weeks and off seasons. Everyone does — including me, and including every client who's ever gotten amazing results with us.

The difference isn't perfection. It's what happens next.

If you want a place where consistency is built in — coaches who know your name, classes that fit your life, and a community that doesn't expect you to be perfect — come try us out. You can get 6 weeks for $1 at any of our five Nova Scotia locations. Grab your trial here and just bring your imperfect self. That's all any of us have ever needed.

Matt

Next
Next

Can Exercise Lower Blood Pressure? What the Research (and My Clients) Say